Close the cold water valve above the heater. Turn the gas control to Off, or switch off the breaker for an electric heater. Then work out where the water is coming from: a fitting can often be fixed, a leaking tank can't. Replacing a hot water tank in Columbus requires a permit, but not plan review.
Key facts
- 1. Water
- Close the cold supply valve above the heater
- 2. Fuel
- Gas control to Off, or electric breaker off
- Leak from a fitting
- Often repairable
- Leak from the tank
- Replacement
- Gas tank, installed
- $1,000–$2,700 (national average range, Fixr)
- Permit
- Replace a hot water tank: permit, no plan review
- Close the cold supply. It's the valve on the pipe going into the top of the heater. If it won't turn, close the house main shutoff.
- Turn off the fuel. Gas heater: turn the control knob to Off. Electric heater: switch off its breaker. If you smell gas, leave the house and call 911 and Columbia Gas of Ohio at 1-800-344-4077 from outside.
Supply closed and fuel off, but water still coming? Call a Columbus plumber, then finish the steps.
Phone line opening soonHave this ready when you call
- Your address
- Where the water is and whether the main is off
- When it started
- Find the leak. Dry the area and look. Top connections, the relief valve, the drain valve near the bottom, or the tank itself.
- Protect the floor. Move boxes, put down towels, and if there's a floor drain, make sure nothing blocks it.
- Drain if a plumber asks you to. Water inside is scalding. Use a hose to a floor drain, and only after the heater has cooled.

Where it leaks decides what happens
| Leak from | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Pipe fittings at the top | Loose or corroded connection; often repairable |
| Relief valve or its pipe | Valve faulty, or pressure or temperature too high; needs a plumber |
| Drain valve | Valve not fully closed or worn; often repairable |
| Tank body or base | Tank has failed; replace it |
Replacing it in Columbus
The city's 2026 typical projects list puts "Replace a hot water tank" under permits without plan review. Your plumber pulls it, since owners can only get plumbing permits for work they do themselves in their own single-family home (BZS FAQ). Fixr's national average range for an installed gas tank is $1,000 to $2,700. Columbia Gas of Ohio's regular rebates have ended, so don't expect one; see rebates.
The plumber
Plumbing contractors working in Columbus need an Ohio OCILB license and city registration, and the city licenses journeyperson plumbers itself (contractor licenses). Check the company in the OCILB lookup.
What a repair usually costs
National ranges from cost publishers, not Columbus quotes. The fault decides the price, so ask for it in writing before work starts.
| Job | National range | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater repair | $150 to $750 | Fixr, updated Aug 2025 |
When you call: 4 questions to ask
- Will you pull the city permit for replacing the hot water tank?
- Is the leak on my side of the curb valve or the city's?
- Can I see your OCILB license and city registration?
- Does the service-call fee count toward the repair?
A fair written quote shows the heater or repair, labor, the permit, haul-away of the old tank and the written warranty. Check any contractor's license on the OCILB company licensee lookup before work starts.
What happens when you call
- You're connectedStraight to a local plumber that serves your area and takes calls like yours.
- You get a priceDescribe the problem, ask for a written quote and their license number. No obligation.
Want a price for your home? Call a local plumber for a written quote.
Phone line opening soonCommon questions
How urgent is a dripping water heater?
It can turn urgent. Close the cold supply and turn off the fuel right away. A small leak at a fitting can wait for a plumber; a leaking tank needs replacing soon.
Does the replacement tank need a city permit?
Yes. Columbus lists "Replace a hot water tank" among jobs that require a permit, but not plan review.
What should I budget for a replacement?
Fixr gives $1,000 to $2,700 as its national average range for a gas tank, installed. No Columbus figure is published.
Related guides
Sources
- Columbia Gas of Ohio: Sewer line safety (gas leak steps and emergency number)
- City of Columbus Building and Zoning Services: Typical residential projects (2026)
- City of Columbus Department of Building and Zoning Services: Frequently asked questions
- Fixr: Gas water heater installation cost
- Columbia Gas of Ohio: Energy efficiency for your home
- City of Columbus: Contractor licenses
- Ohio Department of Commerce: OCILB company licensee lookup
Costs are typical ranges. Your quote depends on your home. Rules and rebates change; check the original source before you rely on a figure. Something wrong? Tell us via the contact on the Impressum page.